If you’re a Beatles fan you certainly remember lyrics from the song, “A Day in the Life.” You know, “Woke up, got out of bed, dragged a comb across my head.”
It certainly applies to the morning routine most of us follow, but doesn’t cover it completely. After all, many men wake up, get out of bed, and are taken aback by what they see in the mirror – namely, bags under their eyes, crow’s feet, dark circles, all of which can make us look older than we are.
It’s not a great way to start your day, but thanks to eye cream – such as Brickell’s Restoring Eye Cream for Men all hope is not lost. Far from it, actually.
Eye cream (and gels and serums) work to reduce the appearance of fine lines, wrinkles, bags, etc., and is a great addition to your grooming kit and routine.
This post focuses on eye cream and our eye cream reviews of the best products for 2020. We’ll also provide some buying tips, how to apply eye cream, and why we have those bags and wrinkles in the first place.
Table of Contents
Balding Beards is reader-supported. When you buy through external links, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more.
|BRICKELL MEN’S EYE RESTORING CREAM FOR MEN||Check on Amazon →|
|TIEGE HANLEY’S AM/PM EYE CREAM (SKIN CARE SYSTEM LEVEL 2)||Check on Tiege.com →|
|CLINIQUE ANTI-AGE EYE CREAM FOR MEN||Check on Amazon →|
|XFACIO EYES EYE CREAM GEL||Check on Amazon →|
|EYE CREAM MOISTURIZER 94% NATURAL ANTI-AGING SKIN CARE||Check on Amazon →|
|ROC RETINOL CORREXION ANTI-AGING EYE CREAM TREATMENT||Check on Amazon →|
|BAEBODY EYE GEL||Check on Amazon →|
Before you buy: 3 Things to consider when purchasing eye cream
If there’s one thing, and one thing only, that you need to pay attention to when buying eye cream for men is its ingredients. Sure, there are a few other factors, but the ingredients make the eye cream.
First, however, a quick “buyer beware.” There are many, many eye creams on the market, most of which come with big bold claims – some of which they can deliver. In that respect, the men’s eye cream market has its share of snake oil elements. Knowing this from the start can help you pick a product that truly works, and we’ll provide a list of creams that we know work.
1. What do you see in the mirror?
Take a minute to make a true assessment of the skin under your eyes. Do you have bags and wrinkles that make you look perpetually tired? If so, cream with hyaluronic acid will flatten and fill in unwanted lines.
If the skin is dry and taut, the hyaluronic acid will help, as will plant-based and vitamin-rich ingredients. Dry skin sufferers typically should look for hydrating skin creams. If you also have dark circles under your eyes, eye creams with caffeine or vitamin K help constrict blood vessels to make those circles fade away.
2. The ingredients
Back to our original point, which is that ingredients make the cream. There are other factors, but always take a long list of a cream’s ingredients before you place it in your shopping cart.
Retinol, a vitamin A derivative, stimulates cell turnover and collagen production which, in turn, strengthens skin while limiting age spots and lines. It also helps to reverse damage caused by the sun’s most harmful rays. Retinol is a key ingredient in most men’s eye creams, but be careful not to use it excessively.
- Hyaluronic Acid
Hyaluronic acid plumps up skin cells and draws moisture to help hydrate skin and flatten those unwanted lines and wrinkles under your eyes.
Ceramides provide a natural barrier to the skin to prevent water loss while making it more supple and moist. Combining ceramides with hyaluronic acid leaves the skin under your eyes looking rested and refreshed.
A neuropeptide isn’t a word used in most people’s everyday vocabulary, but it’s a good one to know if you’re serious about treating the skin under your eyes. Put simply, neuropeptides are particles that prompt the skin to create more collagen and elastin, and thus improve the overall tone and texture of the skin under your eyes.
- Vitamins C & E
The C and E vitamins are powerful antioxidants that fend off free radicals in the skin caused by excessive sun damage. They also act as anti-inflammatories to improve the appearance of dark circles under your eyes. Vitamin C, meanwhile, stimulates collagen and elastin production, while vitamin E soothes the skin and protects it from inflammation.
- Caffeine, Green Tea, and Alpha-Arbutin
Ah, caffeine: that wondrous morning kick-starter. But caffeine isn’t just for coffee drinkers, because you’ll find it in many skin care products – including eye creams. Caffeine and green tea extract reduce swelling and help you get rid of those dark circles under your eyes. They’re also antioxidants that increase blood circulation to help tighten the skin. Alpha-arbutin is a little-known ingredient naturally extracted from bearberry that inhibits the enzyme that leads to dark circles.
Eye creams can do a lot, but they can’t prevent your skin from suffering sun damage. That said, it’s a good idea to choose an eye cream that includes sunscreen with a suitable sun protection factor (which measures how long a sunscreen protects you from the sun’s ultraviolet rays).
Avoid fragrance if you can, because fragrances and other extracts and ingredients may cause skin irritation. Fragrance-free eye cream is your best bet.
3. Your age
Most skin care experts recommend that you begin a daily eye cream regimen at age 21 and over because it helps prevent future problems and may delay the onset of crow’s feet and other signs of aging.
Most men begin to see signs of aging once they reach their 30s. If you’re in that age bracket, look for creams rich in antioxidants that help cell turnover and boost the skin’s natural collagen production. Also look for ingredients such as hyaluronic acid and vitamins C and E to keep your skin looking bright and healthy.
Retinol becomes an important ingredient once you reach your 40s thanks to its anti-aging properties. Also, you should seek creams called deep moisturizers, or have protein added, because they’ll help your skin maintain its moisture, durability, and elasticity.
Let’s move on to our reviews of the best eye cream for men.
The 7 best eye creams for men of 2020
Natural and organic products always get out attention, including Brickell’s Eye Restoring Cream for Men. Then again, Brickell – founded in 2014 – has made a name for itself with a variety of men’s grooming products that fall under the Natural & Organic banner.
But we also like Brickell’s eye cream because it works. If you’re looking for the best eye cream for wrinkles and crow’s feet, this is a cream worthy of your attention.
This cream works for men of any age or skin type and helps to give you brighter, more energized eyes. It’s lightweight and absorbs quickly into the skin but doesn’t leave behind a greasy residue or shine. It also helps get rid of the dark circles and puffiness under your eyes that begin to resemble saddlebags (and make you look like you average only three hours of sleep per night).
Moreover, Brickell’s Men’s Eye Cream strengthens the skin surrounding your eyes. It manages to do all this with a powerful list of natural ingredients, including:
- Hyaluronic Acid – the ultimate skin hydrator
- Caffeine – a natural stimulant that reduces dark circles and puffiness by increasing blood circulation around the eyes
- Matrixyl 3000 – which is a blend of protein peptides that boost collagen production and reduce wrinkles by up to 45% in two months.
- MSM (Methylsulfonylmethane) – Don’t let its synthetic chemical-sounding name fool you; MSM is a nutrient found in superfoods such as spinach and kale and reduces age spots and other common skin pigmentation issues that are part of the aging process.
What you won’t find in Brickell’s Men’s Eye Restoring Cream for Men are potentially harmful chemicals such as sulfates, parabens, phthalates, petrochemicals, silicones, glycols, and synthetic fragrances. It’s also unscented. Brickell doesn’t test its many grooming products on animals, and uses 100% organic ingredients whenever possible.
Brickell advises that you use their cream twice a day while applying a pea-sized amount of it around your eyes in the morning and at bedtime.
- Natural ingredients
- Makes your eyes look more energized, less weary
- Eliminates wrinkles and puffiness
- It may take some time before you see results (but it will work)
You’d do yourself a favor if your search for the right eye cream began with Brickell’s Men’s Eye Restoring Cream. Brickell uses natural ingredients to produce noticeable results. You’ll like what you see in the mirror after using this cream consistently.
Tiege Hanley offers three levels of skincare for men, with each level loaded with quality products that help you to get the best-looking, most comfortable skin that you desire. A key component of its Level 2 System is the AM/PM Eye Cream which has many features that we love.
A blend of caffeine and vitamin B3, among other ingredients in the AM/PM eye cream, helps increase circulation in the skin around your eyes, as well as tightening the skin. It helps you to get rid of those wrinkles, fine lines, and bags around and under your eyes that can help make you look tired and, let’s face it, old.
The caffeine extract found in the AM/PM Eye Cream also works to prevent the sun’s most harmful UV rays from irritating and damaging the skin around your eyes. Vitamin B3, meanwhile, helps improve skin elasticity while reducing discoloration that can add to an overall “tired” look that men would rather avoid.
Another key ingredient found in the AM/PM Eye Cream is acetyl hexapeptide-8, which reduces muscle contraction that can lead to wrinkles.
Men with sensitive skin appreciate that this cream is fragrance-free (fragrances can irritate the skin). And while you’ll get optimal results by applying it morning and night, a little of it goes a long way and you don’t have to worry about your tube running out anytime too soon.
- Reduces puffiness, fine lines, wrinkles, and discoloration
- Improves circulation to the skin around the eyes
- Some say the serum is a bit oily
Tiege Hanely’s AM/PM Eye Serum is another product that does it all when it comes to the health of the skin around your eyes. It’s a gentle yet effective treatment for improving the condition and appearance of your skin.
Countless men and women swear by Clinique’s skin products; the company, after all, is somewhat synonymous with skin care. With products like their Anti-Age Eye Cream For Men, it’s easy to see why.
Clinique understands that the skin around our eyes is usually the first to show signs of aging. That in mind, they’ve designed a hydrating eye cream for men that’s oil-free, and soothes and brightens tired-looking skin around the eyes and its many forms: wrinkles, bags, dark circles, etc. It’s also ophthalmologist-tested, as are all of Clinique’s products.
The Anti-Age Eye Cream hydrates instantly to improve the appearance of fine lines and wrinkles while its formula also acts to strengthen the moisture barrier to leave the skin around your eyes looking radiant and youthful. Many of its users say it produces softer, smoother skin in less time than experienced with other eye creams.
This cream’s list of ingredients is lengthy, to say the least, but includes things such as shea butter, green tea, and caffeine which form a solid line of defense against the effects of aging. It’s also fragrance-free, so you don’t have to worry about its scent following you around all day.
- Superior hydration
- Ophthalmologist-tested for safety
- Works quickly
- The bottle may become clogged after several uses
Clinique is in its 50th year of developing products that meet the skin care needs of individuals, not just the masses. If you’re looking for an eye cream that works quickly and has proven results, Clinique’s Anti-Age Eye Cream for Men is a safe bet.
When someone tells you that you have nice eyes, they’re probably not talking about those circles or bags under your eyes. Fact is, those are things that easily detract from not only the attractiveness of your eyes, but your face as a whole.
Have no fear, friends – Xfacio Labs has a solution, namely, the best under eye cream for men.
First, a bit about Xfacio Labs. Located near Atlanta, Georgia in the U.S., Xfacio’s flagship product is an anti-aging serum that’s applied to the skin. They’re also all about high-concept, scientific skin care with a focus on natural and organic products.
Xfacio Labs’ eye cream increases the hydration of the skin – thanks to hyaluronic acid – while promoting moisture retention that plumps the skin and reduces the appearance of dark circles. Meanwhile, it also contains amino acids that stimulate the production of collagen and elastin to improve the elasticity and firmness of the skin.
But there’s more to the Xfacio Eyes Eye Cream Gel ingredient list, including:
- Jojoba oil – which also helps moisturize the skin
- Vitamin E
- Matrixyl 3000
- MSM – which boosts collagen and keratin production in the skin.
The Eye Cream Gel from Xfacio labs also helps reduce the size of pores while enhancing skin and combating the signs of aging. While it’s second-to-none in dealing with the skin under your eyes, it provides complete care for all types of skin.
- Made from advanced skincare science
- Excellent for clearing up issues of the skin under the eye
- Works to slow the effects of aging
- Some users don’t like its (slight) scent
Xfacio Labs hit a home run with its anti-aging serum and has knocked it out of the park again with its eye cream for men. This natural cream delivers the results you’re looking for in an eye cream.
Another eye cream that’s good for men and women, Eye Cream Moisturizer by Lilyana Naturals is highly-praised, not the least of which is by thousands of reviewers on Amazon.
While there’s nothing in its ingredient list that necessarily makes it stand out from other products in our reviews, the Eye Cream Moisturizer & Anti-Aging Skin Care does include naturals such as vitamin C, vitamin E, rosehip seed oil, and organic hibiscus flower extract.
Rosehip oil regenerates skin, reduces scars and other discoloration, and prevents the progression of lines and wrinkles. Your skin will regain its natural color and tone. Hibiscus extract, a.k.a. as “Nature’s Botox,” provides plumpness, moisture, firmness, and suppleness to the skin while improving its elasticity. We think this is perhaps the best eye cream for puffiness.
So, on second thought, maybe there are some things on this product’s list of ingredients that stand out, after all.
Meanwhile, it doesn’t contain parabens, artificial colors or fragrances, and is manufactured in an FDA-registered USDA Organic-certified facility (and is vegan-friendly). Among its other ingredients are coconut oil, emulsifying wax, sunflower seed oil, neem seed organic oil extract, and rosemary leaf.
Another thing we like about it is that it’s safe for all skin types, including sensitive skin. As we’ve often mentioned in previous product reviews, sensitive skin requires careful attention; you can’t just slather any skincare product on it. But we think this is the best eye cream for sensitive skin.
And it’s not just effective for treating the skin around your eyes, because you can use it on your face and neck to make your skin appear more radiant.
Besides being effective in getting rid of puffiness under the eye, the Eye Cream Moisturizer provides excellent hydration to the skin. Indeed, it continually hydrates and moisturizes.
You can easily use this cream twice a day without worrying about irritation or skin issues.You only need to apply a small amount, so your supply should last a long time. It’s also safe to use it under your makeup.
This product also comes with a 30-day money back guarantee.
- Excellent for removing puffiness under your eyes
- Organic ingredients
- Is safe to use on your face and neck
- Coconut oil may clog pores
A lot of people use – and like – this product although Lilyana Naturals isn’t exactly a household name. It’s an effective, safe product that eliminates puffiness while moisturizing the skin.
You’d be hard-pressed to find an anti-aging product that’s been on the market longer than RoC’s Retinol Correxion Deep Eye Cream. It all began in a Parisian pharmacy 60 years ago and you’ll find the RoC name on hypoallergenic skin care products to SPF sunscreen.
One reason they’ve been around this long is that their stuff works, and that “stuff” includes their Retinol Correxion Anti-Aging Eye Cream Treatment – the best retinol eye cream and the best anti-aging eye cream.
Retinol and anti-aging tend to go hand-in-hand, and RoC’s formula – derived from an essential mineral complex – visibly reduces the signs of aging around the eyes, first by diminishing fine lines and wrinkles, but also crow’s feet, dark circles, and puffiness.
RoC has some research behind it: Johnson & Johnson completed a one-year clinical study proving that the effects of RoC’s retinol don’t plateau and continue to provide benefit with consistent use (note Johnson & Johnson owns RoC but a clinical study is still a clinical study).
You’ll notice a diminishing in fine lines soon after you begin to use RoC Retinol Correxion cream, but you’ll experience more dramatic results when you use it consistently for a month. Not only will your fine lines fade, the dark circles and puffiness under your eyes also fade.
While Retinol degrades if not packaged properly, RoC uses a special aluminum tube that prevents light and air from getting to the cream (and thus degrading it).
RoC isn’t a newcomer to the skin care game, yet keeps re-inventing itself with new formulas that meet the needs of consumers. Their products aren’t all-natural, but they are proven effective for dealing with a variety of skin issues.
- Retinol works as an anti-aging agent
- Best anti-aging cream for 40s
- Visibly reduces lines, wrinkles, dark circles, and puffiness.
- Ingredients aren’t all-natural
RoC knows a thing or two about skin care and their retinol eye cream has years of experience and history behind it. It’s good for all ages and skin types, but if you’re looking to find a product that effectively fights the signs of aging, this is an eye cream you should consider.
Haven’t heard of Baebody’s Eye Gel? By the number of reviews it has on Amazon, you’d be in the minority.
Over 12,000 reviews to be exact – which means men and women have tried (and are using) Baebody’s Gel at an incredibly high rate. OK, so some of the reviews were given in exchange for a free or reduced price product, but the vast majority of them are positive. In other words, they liked it regardless of whether they bought it or received it as a special offer,
So, what’s the big deal? Why is this eye gel garnering so much attention?
Well, it works, for starters. Put simply, Baebody Eye Gel provides an effective, natural solution to getting rid of those irritating issues in the skin around your eyes: from dark circles to puffiness to wrinkles and bags. It’s made by a company in the U.S. that strives for safe, chemical-free solutions to skin care issues.
Their eye gel blends a unique mix of organic and natural ingredients, including plant stem cells. The use of plant stem cells in cosmetics is something of a recent trend, but very popular amongst the anti-aging crowd. Plant stem cells are said to strengthen skin while protecting against sun damage.
We think Baebody is the best eye cream for dark circles because it works to moisturize the skin under your eye while reducing the signs of aging. In fact, Baebody’s Eye Gel includes several ingredients commonly found in anti-aging products: hyaluronic acid, vitamin E, and Matrixyl 3000. Again, Matrixyl 3000 increases collagen production while facilitating skin repair.
It also includes aloe vera, a well-known ingredient that soothes skin irritation.
While Baebody Eye Gel, as its name implies, is meant to treat the skin under and around your eyes, many reviewers say they’ve used it as an anti-aging cream on other parts of their face.
Baebody uses safe, natural ingredients in all of its products. You won’t find parabens, artificial fragrance, dyes, and other fillers in their eye gel, while it manufactures its products in an FDA-registered and GMP (Good Manufacturing Practices)-certified facility. And none of their products are tested on animals.
Baebody advises users to apply their eye gel twice a day, and say it’s OK to use it under makeup.
- Gets rid of dark circles
- Removes puffiness
- Restores and rejuvenates skin
- May cause temporary irritation
Baebody eye gel has a decent amount of hype but it also walks the walk. It handles a myriad of issues that may occur under and around your eyes thanks to a bounty of natural ingredients.
Do it like the pros: How to apply eye cream
You’re going to have to use eye cream if you truly want to get rid of those saddlebags under your eyes, as well as the fine lines and wrinkles around them.
The bad news? The problem only gets worse as you age. While fat shows up in other places of your body as you age – sometimes too prominently – it thins in the area around your eyes, which make dark circles appear more prominent. Meanwhile, the muscles that support your eyes get weaker, which leads to shrinking fluid and tissues – which leads to puffy eye bags.
The good news is that eye cream helps reduce the appearance of saddlebags, crow’s feet and other eye skin issues that make you look old, tired, or both. So, buy a quality eye cream and apply it consistently. Here’s how:
STEP 1: Wash your face thoroughly to remove any dirt, grime, or other foreign matter. These types of particles reduce the effectiveness of your eye cream.
STEP 2: Use only a small amount cream – no more than a pea-sized drop to be exact. Using too much cream prevents it from fully penetrating into the skin.
STEP 3: Apply it twice a day, preferably once in the morning and once more at bedtime. Again, use a small amount with each application.
STEP 4: Use your ring finger to apply it. This prevents you from applying the cream too roughly on your skin.
STEP 5: Don’t “rub” it in! A mistake many people make when applying eye cream is massaging it into their skin as they would lotion or cream on other parts of your body. The skin around your eye is more delicate than other skin and doesn’t respond well to pulling and rubbing. And pulling the skin around your eye can speed up the aging process.
STEP 6: So how do you apply it, if not by rubbing? You “pat” it in instead, which prevents the pulling while making sure you apply the right amount to each area of skin under your eye.
STEP 7: Here’s something else about applying an eye cream that may seem counterintuitive: you don’t apply the cream directly to the problem area. Applying it too close to your eye can cause irritation. Instead, the cream “travels” as your body warms up and will move to the affected area on its own in an hour or two. Whatever you do, don’t let the cream get on your eyelashes because that’s certain to irritate.
STEP 8: Pat the cream around the entire eye, including up to your eyebrow and down until you reach the cheekbone. It’s important to get the area near the top of the eye, even if it’s not as visible.
STEP 9: Let the cream work its way into the skin, which typically takes 15 minutes, before going outside or doing anything else to your face.
STEP 10: If your eyes seem swollen in the morning, don’t assume it’s because you’ve applied the cream at bedtime. Instead, it could be the result of the cream’s ingredients sloping into your eye because of the eye socket’s natural incline.
Why I have bags under my eyes and the difference between eye cream and serum
You may wonder “Why me?” as you examine your eye bags and dark circles in the morning. It’s a good question and one that has some urgency considering that bags, circles, and wrinkles make you look older.
You can blame age, for starters. The skin around your eyes is the most delicate part of your face, as well as the first place on your face that shows signs of aging. It’s skin that’s thinner and dryer than in other areas of your face, while it’s also skin that’s constantly in motion thanks to the movements of our eyes.
But age isn’t the only cause of those saddlebags. Other factors, such as a lack of sleep, smoking, dehydration, excessive use of alcohol, and a high-sodium diet contribute, as well. Also, the skin produces less elastin as we age, and elastin is the protein that’s responsible for the skin to snap back to its original form when it’s pinched or pulled. Think of elastin as thick rubber bands linked together.
Another factor is the environment – weather extremes in particular – while exposure to the sun and regular rubbing of the skin around the eyes are also contributing factors.
Of course, there are also genetics – if your parents (and their parents) had puffy eyes and dark circles the chances are good that you’ll have them, too.
Fortunately, eye cream and eye serum exist to help you deal with the bags, wrinkles, crow’s feet and other assorted crud that forms around your eyes. To this point, we’ve talked almost exclusively about eye cream (and listed some eye “gels”), but we don’t mean to ignore eye serum.
So, eye cream vs. eye serum – what’s the difference?
To be honest, there’s not much difference at all, although skin care experts seem to waver on this fact. Nonetheless, here’s a look at the similarities and differences between eye cream and eye serum.
First, their similarities:
- They’re used as an anti-aging eye treatment
- They sometimes come in different forms
- They provide essentially the same benefits
But there are differences:
- Creams have a more viscous texture while serums are a bit more gel-like. This matters because – in general – the skin under the eye absorbs serum more rapidly than cream because of its gel-like consistency.
- Eye creams are often thought to be better for the maintenance and prevention of skin problems. Serums, however, are effective in fixing skin that’s already damaged because, in part, they encourage the skin to produce more elastin.
- We’ve already discussed many of the ingredients found in an eye cream. Most serums include the same ingredients, including the anti-aging fighter retinol, along with natural proteins called neuropeptides that accelerate the production of collagen.
So, which one is better?
The fact is, there doesn’t seem to be much of a clearcut answer. Again, eye creams work very effectively in reducing the appearance of fine lines, bags, and wrinkles, while serums work to fix skin that’s already damaged (and needs a bit more help).
While some folks argue that eye serum is simply a more potent version of eye cream, others say that there isn’t any difference and it all comes down to marketing. In other words, the results of using either aren’t a helluva lot different.
Choosing the best eye cream for men
A general Google search of eye cream – or, for that matter, skin cream – and scams will generate plenty of results. It seems that the world of skincare is well-populated with shady salesmen and women who make grandiose claims, including one product marketed as the “Amazing new Hollywood secret!”
For us, the task of choosing the best eye cream for men demanded that we steer clear of scammers while always keeping a suspicious eye peeled for products that do everything from eliminating saddlebags to starting your car for you each morning (OK, so maybe they didn’t go that far). And that meant reading online reviews carefully, as well as studying each product’s list of ingredients.
Price is always a factor in our reviews as we aim to create a best-products list that fits every budget. We also prefer natural products without a heavy dose of chemicals, although we respect any product as long as it works and doesn’t cause irritation.
How about you? Do you have a favorite eye cream? Have you tried any on our list? Let us know. We always appreciate your feedback and suggestions.
Talk to you soon.