7 Best Aftershaves for Men Your Skin Would Love [Aug. 2017]

best aftershaveIf you’re not using an aftershave, then you’re missing out on an essential part of shaving.

Sure, you need a quality razor, the best in shave cream and shave soap, a great shaving brush, and the desire to use all of these elements to produce the smoothest, most comfortable shave possible.

But aftershave is like medicine for your skin, for lack of a better description. It helps take care of issues such as razor cuts, burns, ingrown hairs, and you can find one that’s suitable for every skin type.

Like anything else, however, the aftershave market contains both quality and low-quality products, but led by Proraso’s Aftershave Lotion , we want to put you in touch with only the best ones.

In this post, we’ll not only discuss the best aftershaves available, but also break them down by different types and, as always, give you some things to consider before you buy.

Contents:

Before You Buy: 4 Things to Consider When Purchasing Aftershave

First, a quick thought about aftershave, something that definitely will inform your buying decision. And the thought is this: an aftershave’s scent should be a small part of the equation when you’re shopping for the product that best suits you.

After all, you can get a decent scent with a cheap cologne – but don’t go crazy when you apply it.

But aftershave has a much more important role than simply making you smell good, and the main reason is that it’s good for your face. Aftershaves help prevent infections that may occur from cuts and nicks you get from shaving because they contain an antiseptic element.

Aftershaves also contain moisturizers that soften that skin after a shave as well as “cooling” it following the friction of your shave.

So, yes, you want to consider an aftershave’s scent before you buy it. But there’s a plenty of other things to consider before choosing one for your morning routine.

1. Types

There are four primary types of aftershave: splash, lotion, gel, or balm. Choosing the right one for you depends on your skin type.

  • Normal skin

If you have normal skin, the splash type of aftershave is best for you.

  • Oily skin

Splashes, lotions, and gels will work well if you have oily skin.

  • Dry skin

If you have dry skin – and live in a cold or dry climate – balm types of aftershaves are a good choice for you, especially if you’re just starting to use aftershaves.

  • Sensitive skin

For men with sensitive skin, the best bet is to choose aftershave that’s paraben-free and doesn’t contain alcohol that can burn the skin.

2. Ingredients

The two major aftershave ingredients to look for are witch hazel and alcohol. Let’s take a closer look at each of them:

  • Witch Hazel

When you think of witch hazel, think “natural.” It’s a natural astringent for your pores and is the main ingredient in all kinds of beauty products. As an aftershave, it works to constrict your pores without drying out your skin.

Witch hazel also has anti-inflammatory qualities that help soothe irritated skin. You’ll also find it in products such as those used to treat bug bites and rashes.

Finally, witch hazel is effective in cleaning the skin because it flushes out bacteria – including bacteria that can cause acne.

  • Alcohol

Men and women have used rubbing alcohol as a means to scrub their skin for ages. The problem is, alcohol will aggravate irritated skin (and sting when you apply it to your face). Moreover, alcohol will dry out your skin. Are we suggesting that witch hazel is the better ingredient in aftershave? Yes, we are.

3. Other ingredients

Like witch hazel, there are other natural ingredients that you should look for when choosing an aftershave.

  • Tea Tree Essential Oil

Tea tree oil is a natural antiseptic that flushes out the pores of your face to help prevent skin infections. A mix of tea tree oil and witch hazel is very soothing on your face after you shave.

  • Aloe Vera

You’ve certainly heard of – and used – aloe vera and its considerable soothing qualities. It helps heal burned skin and lessens the pain; so you know the stuff is good when it’s applied to irritated skin after a shave.

  • Humectants

Humectants such as glycerol, sorbitol, and lactic acid are often found in aftershaves and help minimize the dehydrating effects of other active ingredients.

4. Fragrance

OK, our heads aren’t so far in the sand that we don’t think scent will be at least part of your buying decision. So, let’s take a closer look:

  • Fragrance duration

How long a scent lasts on your skin depends on many variables, not the least of which is body chemistry and skin type. Oils are the main ingredient in fragrances and will dissipate more quickly when applied to dry skin. However, the fragrance will last longer when applied to oily skin.

Alcohol, meanwhile, also affects fragrance duration because it evaporates quickly. If the aftershave contains less fragrance (but also alcohol), the scent will fade at a faster rate.

  • Types of fragrance

The most popular types of fragrances used in aftershave are floral, citrus, oriental, and woody. It’s important to note that quality fragrances are multi-layered and appeal to a person’s sense of smell in three stages, top, middle, and base.

The top layer of the fragrance is what you’ll smell when first opening the bottle. But that layer lasts the least amount of time, while the middle layer makes up the bulk of the fragrance. The base layer comes out when the top layer has completely evaporated and combines with the middle layer to provide the lasting scent.

Now let’s move on to the heart of the matter – the best aftershaves available today.

The 7 best aftershaves of 2017

1. Proraso Aftershave Lotion, Refreshing and Toning

Proraso Aftershave Lotion, Refreshing and ToningProraso’s Aftershave Lotion takes you back to the golden age of barber shops when a haircut and a shave was something every man looked forward to with enthusiasm. You know, the hot towel to soften your beard, the super-close shave with a quality straight razor, and all followed by a splash of fragrant, refreshing aftershave on both cheeks.

But that’s not a surprise when you consider that Proraso has been around since 1948 and is one of Italy’s most iconic brand names. Proraso’s products are a staple of Italy’s culture and have evolved with all-natural formulas that don’t include parabens, silicones, or artificial colors.

Their Refreshing and Toning lotion is both the best aftershave for men and the best aftershave lotion. Proraso also makes an excellent aftershave balm.

Moreover, we’ve also reviewed Proraso’s superb shaving soap and shave cream in previous posts. If you’re truly serious about wet shaving, then you owe it to yourself to check out all of Proraso’s products.

But back to their aftershave lotion, which is of superior quality for a variety of reasons:

  • The lotion is formulated with a selection of fresh, natural ingredients. Eucalyptus oil tones purify your skin and facial hair, while menthol refreshes and revitalizes your face after you shave. Witch hazel is also included and reduces rashes and razor burns.
  • It has a pleasant scent that is clean, mild, and doesn’t linger the entire day. It will dissipate within an hour or two and blends well with colognes.
  • You’ll love the price, as you can purchase the Refreshing and Toning Lotion on Amazon for $14. When you consider that many quality aftershaves sell for upwards of $40 … well, you get the picture.
  • You’ll like the immediate relief this lotion provides after your shave and the fact that it refreshes and tones your skin.
  • Proraso Aftershave Lotion includes no animal-based ingredients to make it vegan-friendly.

Type

Lotion

Pros

  • Over 95% natural ingredients
  • Refreshes and revitalizes the skin after shaving
  • Pleasant scent that doesn’t linger

Cons

  • Scent has a slight medicinal smell

Bottom Line

Proraso is known for its superior wet shaving products, and its Aftershave Lotion is certainly no exception. You’ll love the way your face feels after gently massaging this lotion into your skin.

2. The Art of Shaving Sandalwood Aftershave Balm

The Art of Shaving Sandalwood Aftershave BalmThe folks at The Art of Shaving have famously said that a man shaves 20,000 times in an average lifetime and has the choice of making his daily ritual one to remember or one to perform every day with all the enthusiasm of watching grass grow.

They’d obviously prefer that you let someone else stare at the grass.

The Art of Shaving is an online source for some of the best-wet shaving products you’ll find, including their awesome Aftershave Balm.

They claim – the people at The Art of Shaving, that is – that the perfect shave consists of four elements – preparation, lathering, shaving, and moisturizing. They take care of the final step with the best aftershave balm on the market.

The Art of Shaving Aftershave Balm accomplishes several things while bringing your perfect shave to its conclusion. For one, it replenishes moisture to help soothe dry skin after shaving while also revitalizing and conditioning the skin.

The result is soft, well-moisturized skin that isn’t plagued by the dreaded aftershave burn. The Aftershave Balm’s list of ingredients includes shea butter and a touch of grapeseed extract – both of which nourish the skin.

The balm also serves as an antiseptic and is alcohol-free which, again, means no burn. And here’s another thing: all of The Art of Shaving’s products are Aromatherapy-based and scented with 100% pure essential oils. That’s why their products are notable for therapeutic skin properties, as well as blended for a variety of skin types.

You’ll also like its Sandalwood scent, which has a masculine woody undertone that makes for a calming aroma. It’s light enough to be used with your favorite cologne.

What you won’t find in The Art of Shaving’s Sandalwood Aftershave Balm are parabens and sulfates. That’s why it’s ideal for men with sensitive skin.

Type

Balm

Pros

  • Replenishes and moisturizes the skin
  • Cools razor burn
  • Light, pleasing sandalwood scent

Cons

  • Some reviewers say the company changed the original formula

Bottom Line

The Art of Shaving takes wet shaving seriously, and their Sandalwood Aftershave Balm is a product for anyone who feels the same. Regularly applying this balm after your shave will keep your skin nourished and comfortable.

3. Lab Series 3-in-1 Post-Shave Remedy

Barberry Coast Bay Rum Aftershave SplashAh, the torment of pseudo-folliculitis barbae. If you suffer from it or have suffered from it, you have our sympathies.

We’re talking about razor bumps or, to break it down even further – ingrown hair. The latter is the cause of razor bumps, which contribute to a fairly lousy shaving experience for anyone who has to deal with them.

But that’s where Lab Series 3-in-1 Post Shave Remedy enters the picture. While plenty of aftershaves claim to deal with pseudo-folliculitis barbae effectively, Lab Series 3-in-1 Post Shave Remedy doesn’t just talk the talk.

Ingrown hairs result when newly-shaved hairs curl back toward the face and eventually penetrate the skin. They’re uncomfortable as hell and trying to shave over and around them is usually a pain in the ass. The 3-in-1 Post Shave Remedy helps relieve and prevent ingrown hairs and subsequent razor bumps.

The 3-in-1 gel has a blend of plant-based ingredients that help refine beard hair. Users notice results in as few as two weeks when their facial hair comes back thinner and finer. The gel also increases the skin’s exfoliation process to allow hair follicles to remain open – meaning that your facial hair grows out instead of inward.

So, we’ve already touched on the three benefits mentioned in the Post Shave Remedy’s name, but it’s worth listing them; 1) It soothes skin to leave it feeling refreshed and invigorated; 2) It influences beard growth by ensuring that it comes back softer and finer than before, and 3) It moisturizes your face to leave it feeling refreshed and invigorated.

One of its other attributes is that it slows down beard growth on the areas of the face where it’s applied. That’s not ideal for would-be beard growers, of course, but were only talking about the parts of your face that you keep clean-shaven.

Finally, 3-in-1 Post Shave Remedy’s long list of natural ingredients – which doesn’t include parabens – provide antioxidant protection that helps renew the skin after shaving.

Then again, Lab Series products have delivered excellent results since the company formed 30 years ago. Their line includes anti-aging and oil control products. You’ll find their products in over 30 countries.

Type

Gel

Pros

  • Prevents razor bumps and burn
  • It’s an excellent moisturizer
  • Controls the growth of facial hair

Cons

  • Not many, but it’s not for you if you prefer something with fragrance

Bottom Line

The 3-in-1 Post Shave Remedy is truly a unique product, and it’s one that’s lab-developed and tested. It does more than just soothe your face after you’ve run a razor over it.

4. Jack Black Post Shave Cooling Gel

Jack Black Post Shave Cooling GelWe all should strive to get the best shave possible every time we step in front of the bathroom mirror, or grab our razor while in the shower. Like everything else in life, we may not always be on top of our game.

Whatever the reason – lack of attention, a dull blade, weariness – your shave becomes a battleground in which the skin on your face loses every time. Nicks. Cut. Razor bumps.

Damn it.

But not all is lost. A quality aftershave will salvage an otherwise dreary experience and Jack Black’s Post Shave Cooling Gel will put you back on the right track. It’s an alcohol-free, soothing lotion that wins the battle against razor burn, redness, and irritation due to shaving. Better yet, it doesn’t sting your face like other aftershaves, and who needs additional discomfort after an uncomfortable shave?

And there’s more:

  • Jack Black’s Post Shave Cooling Gel has a cooling effect that closes your pores after your shave while calming what feels like a hornet’s nest on your face.
  • It contains aloe extracts, and we all know how beneficial aloe is in treating irritated skin. Chamomile and witch hazel also help soothe your face.
  • Another of its ingredients is sage, which helps regulate the circulation of blood to your hair follicles while promoting healthy hair growth.
  • The Post Shave Cooling Gel also contains lavender oil, which has antiseptic qualities that help heal the skin after a rough shave. It even helps reduce the pain and redness caused by sunburns.
  • It’s paraben, fragrance, and colorant free. It’s also vegan, and certainly among the best natural aftershave products available.

Reviewers and everyday shavers also like the fact that you need only to apply a small amount to your face to get its full benefits.

Type

Lotion

Pros

  • Heals, hydrates, and calms irritated skin
  • Natural ingredients
  • It even protects the skin from UV damage

Cons

  • No fragrance (if you like fragrance)

Bottom Line

It’s hard to beat this lotion if your face is irritated easily (and after a bad shave). But it’s good for anyone no matter their skin type, and the fact that you can use it as sunburn protection is worth noting.

5. Barberry Coast Bay Rum Aftershave Splash

Barberry Coast Bay Rum Aftershave SplashThe scent of Bay Rum conjures up images of grizzled sailors and pirates who sailed ‘round the Caribbean Islands centuries ago. After months spent on the open sea, sailors reached land in desperate need of a shave and, well, anything that helped them smell better.

Enter Bay Rum aftershave, which resolved both the issue of taming irritated skin and the problem of stinking like someone who just spent significant time away from land.

Bay Rum was effective then and it’s effective now. The Barberry Coast Shave Co. has wedded the past and present into an aftershave splash that smells great and is healthy for your post-shave skin. It’s a combination that’s hard to beat.

The best aftershave splash on the market, as well as the best smelling aftershave, Barberry Coast’s Bay Rum splash is handcrafted with all-natural ingredients and aged to perfection (for at least 30 days) before it’s made available to the buying public.

Barberry Coast uses glycerin, not alcohol, to help moisturize your face without the stinging and other irritation that may come with alcohol-based products.

The Bay Rum Aftershave includes a unique blend of exotic spices, citrus, essential oils, and extracts – as well as the essence of bay leaves found in the West Indian Islands. Again, its ingredients are all-natural, vegan, with no GMO oils or parabens.

Applying this splash to your face after a shave will give you a quick burning sensation that’s not at all uncomfortable and will awaken your senses. You’ll not only feel ready to face the world, but you’ll smell damn good, too. And some men suggest the Bay Rum is like catnip for the ladies (it’s worth a try, anyway).

Here’s another thing to like about Barberry Coast Bay Rum Aftershave Splash: It comes with a 100% lifetime guarantee. If you don’t like it, for any reason, you’ll get a full refund.

Type

Splash

Pros

  • Excellent scent
  • All-natural ingredients
  • Money-back guarantee

Cons

  • Scent may be too strong for some

Bottom Line

Barberry Coast is in the business of producing unique men’s grooming products, and its Bay Rum Aftershave Splash is unlike any other. It smells great, but also provides excellent re-moisturizing and replenishing for your skin.

6. Lather & Wood Shaving Co. After Shave Balm

Lather & Wood Shaving Co. After Shave BalmThe first thing you’ll notice about Lather & Wood’s After Shave Balm is that it’s thicker than other balms – though not overly so. But it has a texture that’s more buttery than lotion, and it’s non-greasy, non-sticky, and easy to apply.

You’ll also notice that it’s a very good aftershave.

There are plenty of quality aftershave balms on the market but Lather & Wood’s After Shave Balm rises to the top of the list thanks to its many benefits. And, for one, it’s perhaps the best aftershave for sensitive skin available.

For men with sensitive skin, an aftershave that doesn’t burn and irritate the face after a shave is a must. The Lather & Wood After Shave Balm is alcohol-free, and contains coconut oil – which is naturally moisturizing, antifungal, and antibacterial, while Jojoba oil is included to help control your skin’s natural oil production.

It also includes vitamin E, an antioxidant that has anti-aging qualities. Its other ingredients include rosemary leaf extract, organic neem seed oil, and witch hazel (not alcohol).

Users like the fact it’s a balm that naturally cools the skin without drying it out or leaving an oily residue. Again, when an aftershave balm dries out your skin, it’s because it usually contains alcohol, which this balm doesn’t.

The Lather & Wood After Shave Balm is described by some as being unscented, while others notice a slight sandalwood scent.

While made in small batches, a little of Lather & Wood’s balm goes a long way, with some users saying that one bottle can last up to eight months.

Type

Balm

Pros

  • Great for sensitive skin
  • Excellent texture
  • Natural ingredients

Cons

  • Not many, although some users wish the slight sandalwood scent was stronger

Bottom Line

Lather & Wood’s After Shave Balm is unlike most other balms out there, but different is good in this case. You’ll love its texture and non-oily feel, and it doesn’t contain alcohol. While it’s great for men with sensitive skin, it’s a good all-around balm.

7. Nivea Men Original Replenishing Post Shave Balm

Nivea Men Original Replenishing Post Shave BalmNivea is fairly new to the U.S. market, but their lotions have been available in Germany for over a century. They also offer more than 1,600 products, including their iconic Nivea Crème, as well as their Nivea Men Original Replenishing Post Shave Balm, which is proving to be a hit in America.

Nivea also offers a post shave balm for men with sensitive skin, but many users have found the Original Replenishing Post Shave Balm to be just as effective with skin that’s easily irritated. The difference is that the latter contains more alcohol – and leaves a mild burning sensation after it’s applied.

But it’s still a good aftershave.

Nivea’s Original has a mild, non-greasy formula that uses Vitamin E and Provitamin B5 that replace and regenerate skin, while special moisturizers provide long-lasting moisture. Your skin will feel refreshed and replenished long after you’ve shaved and the balm absorbs quickly into your skin.

And while, again, it’s not sold as being specifically for men with sensitive skin, it helps protect against skin irritation and men with touchier skin will like that. But it is a bit stronger than the sensitive skin version, no question.

The only real drawback with this balm is its scent, which some critics say is too strong and too stereotypical of masculine drug store scent.

Type

Balm

Pros

  • Vitamin E and B5 regenerate, replenish skin
  • Long-lasting moisture
  • Absorbs quickly into the skin

Cons

  • Strong scent bothers some users

Bottom Line

Yes, it uses alcohol – not witch hazel – but this is still a good product that’s effective for soothing skin after a shave. And some users say the Original version is just as good for sensitive skin as the one designed for sensitive skin.

Be Kind to Your Face: (How to) Apply Aftershave

Applying aftershave, like applying shave soap, shave cream, or shaving, is like a lot of things in life, i.e., it seems simple enough, but there’s more to it than meets the eye.

No, it doesn’t require a degree in chemical engineering. But there is a “right” way and a “wrong” way and using a bit of technique when applying your aftershave will keep your face feeling great the whole day.

Many have weighed in on the proper way to get that soothing, healing, refreshing aftershave on your face, including this very helpful video:

We can also break it down – step-by-step – in writing.

  1. Immediately after you’ve shaved, pat your face with cold water to close your skin pores and then gently dry your face with a clean towel.
  2. Put a small amount of aftershave (balm, lotion, gel, splash) in the palm of your hand. Gently rub your hands together to spread the product evenly.
  3. Use an upward, circular motion to massage the lotion into the newly-shaven areas of your face. This type of motion helps your face absorb the product quickly.
  4. Let the aftershave soak into your skin until it’s no longer visible; this could take a few minutes. In some cases, you may have to apply a second coat of aftershave to ensure that you’ve covered all areas of your face.

A couple of other thoughts when it comes to applying aftershave: 1) You can use a moisturizer on your face after you shave and before you apply aftershave, especially if you use a product that contains alcohol – which can dry the skin out, 2) You may also want to apply witch hazel to your face after you’ve shaved to remove any residue that was left behind after you rinsed your face. This isn’t a mandatory step, however, and many of the best aftershaves already contain witch hazel.

What’s the Difference: Balm, Splash, Lotion, Gel?

As indicated by our product reviews, aftershave comes in many different forms, with the main types being balm, splash, lotion, and gel. We’ve already discussed what type of aftershave is best for different types of facial skin, but let’s dig deeper and take a closer look at each type.

Aftershave Balm

Put simply, aftershave balm is a hydrating lotion with a mild scent – but not always – that goes away shortly after you apply it to your face. Balms are usually alcohol-free – but not always – and are effective in reducing the effects of razor burns after shaving. You may notice a slight stinging sensation when you first apply balm to your face, but they’re very effective in tightening the pores of your skin.

Balms are great for men with dry skin because they’re ultra-lubricating and stay close to the surface of the skin. They’re thicker and heavier than other types of aftershave, and you should avoid them if you’re acne-prone.

Splash

Splash is an antiseptic that is often alcohol-based that tightens and dries the skin. They’re good for cut and nick-prone men because they work to prevent infection. If you have dry skin, avoid alcohol-based splashes and stick with those that use witch hazel instead. If you have oily skin that can stand a bit of dryness, use an aftershave splash.

Lotion

Like splash, aftershave lotions tend to have a strong scent than other types of aftershaves. The scent may even be strong and long-lasting enough for you to use it in place of cologne. The lotion works as a skin toner and tightens the pores after shaving. Lotions work great with oily skin.

Gel

There’s not a huge difference between aftershave lotions and gels, but gels are great for cooling down your skin and reducing post-shave burning. The skin quickly absorbs gel, which makes them great for humid climates when you know you’re going to be sweating soon after your shave. Because they absorb so quickly, gels may not provide enough moisturizing for some.

How We Chose The Best Aftershave of 2017

What makes for a quality aftershave? We hope we’ve answered at least part of that question with our reviews while giving you some ideas on what products are best for you.

In choosing the best aftershaves of 2017, we took a variety of factors into consideration, including ingredients, how they feel on the skin, and – of course – how effective they are. As with all of our reviews, we did a lot of research and perused the reviews of others who care as much as we do about proper grooming.

While it we don’t have the time to try every aftershave available, we’re confident in our ability to weed out the mediocre (or worse) products while uncovering the best.


With that, we’ll wrap up another of our “Best of” product reviews. As always, we encourage your feedback and welcome any comments – whether they’re about the products listed in this post or a personal favorite that didn’t make the list. We’d love to hear from you.

You might also like:

6 Best Shaving Soaps for an Old-School, Effective Shave

7 Best Shaving Creams That Will Guarantee a Great Shave

6 Best Shaving Brushes That Will Up Your Shave Quality

7 Best Safety Razor Blades That Provide a Perfect Shave

5 Best Razors for Sensitive Skin: Shaving Without Irritation

Leave a Reply

scalp micropigmentation hair tattoo
The Hair Tattoo a.k.a. Scalp Micropigmentation: Should You Do It?
best hair loss treatment for men
Best Hair Loss Treatment For Men: A No-Nonsense Guide
should you shave your head
7 Things About Shaving Your Head (And When It’s Time)
bald with a beard
Why You Seriously Need a Beard with a Bald Head
how to grow a thicker beard
5 Proven Ways How You Can Grow a Thicker Beard (Faster and Better)
beard clubs
21 Beard and Mustache Clubs Around The World You Should Check Out
rogaine for facial hair
The Minoxidil Beard: How to Use Rogaine to Thicken Your Facial Hair
bald with a beard
Why You Seriously Need a Beard with a Bald Head
grooming mistakes men make
11 Grooming Mistakes You Might Be Making – Including What’s ‘Down There’
how to layer clothing men
How to Layer Your Clothes the Right Way (Men)
how to apply cologne
How to Apply Cologne Like a Man, Not an Animal
what is beard oil and its benefits
What is Beard Oil and What Are Its Benefits?
Beard Grooming Body Grooming Face Shaving Hair Cutting & Head Shaving Miscellaneous Treating Hair Loss
best beard oil
13 Best Beard Oils and Conditioners: A Review & Guide [Aug. 2017]
best bar soap for men
7 Best Bar Soaps for Men Your Skin Will Thank You For [Aug. 2017]
best aftershave
7 Best Aftershaves for Men Your Skin Would Love [Aug. 2017]