Hair gel is one of those products that has been around forever while maintaining steady popularity among men. It’s also come a long way from its humble beginnings – which trace back a few thousand years – and works with almost every hairstyle and texture.
That’s a good thing, no doubt, but it can make choosing the right gel for you more challenging. We’re here to help by identifying the best hair gel for men, including American Crew’s Firm Hold Styling Gel while providing reviews, buying tips, a how-to for applying gel, and how gel compares to other men’s styling products.
It all comes down to making your hair look its best, and simply shampooing and conditioning your hair isn’t necessarily going to do that. That’s where products like gel come in: they help you lock in your favorite hairstyle while giving it a look that others will admire.
If you haven’t already, it may be time to add hair gel to your grooming kit.
- Before you buy: 5 Things to consider when purchasing hair gel
- 9 Best hair gels for men 2019
- What’s the right way to apply hair gel? (A simple, 4-step illustrated guide)
- Hair gel vs. all the rest
- Why did we choose these products?
Before You Buy: 5 Things To Consider When Purchasing Hair Gel
Your first step in the process is determining what hair gel is right for you. As always, we’ll offer our choices for what we think are the best hair gels, but it’s also helpful to have an idea what to look for when you consider which gel to buy.
1. Hair Type
What type of hair you have is an important consideration before buying any styling product. Whether you have curly, thin, coarse, fine, thick hair, choose a gel that’s appropriate to that type.
2. Hair Style
It’s also important to choose a gel that works for your hairstyle. Are you going for a more traditional look or do you prefer the tousled, “messy” look that many men favor today?
A product’s hold refers to its strength for keeping your hair in place. A gel with a stronger hold will “set” your style in place so that you probably won’t have to restyle it during the day when a few hairs go out of place. A weaker hold means that you can restyle it (and works well for many “natural” hairstyles). Meanwhile, a medium hold indicates that you can do some midday styling, but nothing too complicated.
Shine means just that, i.e., how shiny your hair is after you’ve applied gel to it. The higher the shine, the more slicked-back your hair will look. Many hair gel brands have a high shine, as do traditional pomades and waxes. Again, it all depends on the look that you’re trying to achieve.
A hair gel’s list of ingredients varies from brand to brand, but keep in mind that many of them contain alcohol. While alcohol often gets a bad rap, it also has some benefits for hair – including that it works as an anti-bacterial agent. Another type of alcohol – fatty alcohol – isn’t an astringent but instead helps to retain moisture on the surface of your skin. Plus, they’ll improve your hair’s overall smoothness.
Many gels are water soluble, which makes them easy to wash out of your hair, and some contain antioxidants. Lanolin wax is another ingredient you’ll commonly find in gels, while some products contain artificial fragrance, which isn’t necessarily a good thing.
That covers some hair gel buying tips. Let’s move on to our hair gel reviews.
The 9 Best Hair Gels For Men 2019
American Crew’s Firm Hold Styling Gel gets high marks from a variety of reviewers – and users – for many reasons, not the least of which is its versatility. After all, it works well with many hair types and styles, and it’s easy to apply and makes getting your favored look simple.
And once you get your preferred style you don’t have to worry about it falling out of place. As its name suggests, it has a firm hold that lasts all day, especially for shorter to medium-length hairstyles. You’ll like the control it gives you without worrying if you need to restyle your hair during the day.
But there’s more:
- It’s hard to beat the Firm Hold Styling Gel regarding texture. It lifts your hair to give it a thicker – and healthier look
- It works well on both wet and dry hair
- While it has a firm hold, it doesn’t have a lot of rigidity as do many other gels
- It doesn’t have a heavy shine
- It’s water-soluble and easy to wash out of your hair, and it won’t leave flakes behind
- It has a natural fragrance that’s just the right potency but not overpowering
Another thing to like about American Crew’s Firm Hold Styling Gel is that it’s alcohol-free and that its list of ingredients includes natural extracts such as vitamin B5, Panama bark, and sage and ginseng. Vitamin B5 is among the best vitamins for hair care, including that you’ll often find it in products that treat hair loss and thinning hair.
You don’t need to use a ton of the Crew’s Firm Hold Styling Gel to get your desired results. Just a small squeeze should do, and considering that it comes in a hefty 33.8-ounce bottle it’s going to last you a long time.
- Has a firm hold that isn’t stiff
- Good for most hair types and styles
- Provides excellent texture
- Not many, although its large bottle doesn’t travel well
The favorite of many, many men, you owe it to yourself to give this styling gel a try. It gives you the kind of hold you’d expect (given its name) but doesn’t leave your hair feeling stiff, crunchy, or weighted down.
Johnny B. Mode Hair Care prides itself on providing the best quality products for men who visit barbershops and salons. But you can also buy it online, and the company earns its reputation by strategically analyzing consumer preferences and needs.
Its Styling Gel reflects their commitment to developing quality products that are relevant to today’s man. It has a thick formula that supplies a medium hold and allows room for flexibility and restyling throughout the day.
But the first thing you’ll notice about this gel is its sky blue color. It looks great and also smells fantastic with a fragrance that’s cologne-like but not overpowering. It’s also easy to apply, although you only need a use a small amount to get the style and hold you need for most hair types.
Another thing about its hold – it’s strong enough for thick hair even though it doesn’t have the same stiff hold of other products. It will last you throughout the day and has just enough hardening to let you know its there (and to keep stray hairs in place).
The Johnny B. Mode Styling Gel is water soluble, so it rinses out easily between applications, and won’t cause flakes or unwanted buildup on your hair. And while it feels thick when you first put it in your hands, it eventually has a lightweight feel.
You’ll get a nice, pleasant shine from this gel but not the glossiness that doesn’t work for a lot of men – especially for those whose hair is already on the greasy side.
You can apply the Styling Gel to wet or dry hair. Blow drying your hair after you apply it will help you get the best styling results.
Johnny B. Mode’s Styling Gel doesn’t contain alcohol, although it does have fragrance added. But that’s not necessarily a bad thing given how nice it smells.
This video will give you another look at the Johnny B. Mode Styling Gel:
- Has just the right amount of hold
- Easy to wash out
- Lasts long and smells great
- Make sure you buy it from a reputable, online seller
The Johnny B. Mode Styling Gel does everything you’d expect from a high-quality product. It gives you an all-day hold without feeling heavy, it’s easy to apply and rinse out, and it smells great.
While Clubman’s Styling Gel may qualify as a “budget” choice, there’s nothing cheap about it. Instead, it’s one of the best hair gels for men available today.
What makes it so good? A lot of reasons, really, including its manly scent that reminds you of barbershop scents. It won’t overpower you – which is always a plus – but it’s just noticeable enough to let you and others know it’s there.
But the scent is never a primary concern when we evaluate various hair styling products because it always comes down to performance and effectiveness. The Clubman Styling Gel by Ed Pinaud answers the bell in both categories and earns high marks from users and reviewers alike.
Let’s start its versatility: you can adjust its hold to be extremely stiff by applying it with your hands and leaving it in the hair, or you can get a lighter hold – that lets your hair have movement – by applying it and then using a comb or brush to thin it out and leave a more even coating.
While men with thicker hair can choose Clubman’s Styling Gel and get good results, it works best for on medium length hair because of its somewhat lighter hold. It’s a hold that will last the day, mind you, but it’s not so stiff that your hair wouldn’t move in a hurricane. Instead, your hair will feel soft, and the gel washes out easily.
The Clubman Styling Gel has a natural shine that isn’t glaring. If you want a higher shine, you can add a bit of water as you apply it.
We also like this gel’s list of ingredients, which includes castor oil and wheat protein, which both have hair health benefits. It’s also alcohol-free.
- Non-greasy texture
- The hold is adjustable
- Great scent
- A small number of users report flaking
The Clubman Styling Gel isn’t just good for the price, but simply one of the best hair gels for men no matter the cost. It helps gives your hair a natural look and feel while its scent is a nice bonus.
TIGI Bed Head goes the distance in creating products for men that deliver proven results. Their Power Play Gel certainly earns high marks and it’s an excellent product for men looking for a hold that’s neither too strong nor too light.
It’s also an excellent gel for men with long and thick hair who are looking for a strong style while maintaining a natural look. One could argue that it’s the best hair gel for thick hair. It’s also a good choice for active men who want the right amount of hold to maintain their style but while still retaining their hair’s natural look.
While it’s superior when used on long hair, it’s also effective if your hair is wavy, straight, or curly. It has a matte finish that’s never going to look greasy.
The Power Play Gel as a creamy, smooth texture that’s non-sticky. It may feel a little thick when you first apply it but it settles nicely into your hair without making it feel stiff. To get more of a crisp, crunchier look, apply it to damp hair and use a blower dryer to set it.
Like many of the quality gels on our list, TIGI’s Bed Head gel for men washes out easily, and it won’t leave any flakes or other residue. It’s alcohol-free and contains antioxidants that are good for the hair and scalp.
- Non-greasy finish
- Medium hold that feels just right
- Great for men with thicker hair
- Some users don’t like the fragrance
The Power Play Gel has too many attributes to leave it off our reviews. From its natural hold to its non-sticky formula, there’s a lot to like about this product.
If you’re a man who prefers or needs a gel that provides a high hold, then Style Sexy’s Hair Hard Up Gel is a product you need to try.
Few products offer the kind of hold you’ll find in this gel. That’s good news for men who have hairstyles that need to stay in place without much, if any, movement, even in extreme weather or as your grinding through a hard workout at the gym.
One of the reasons why this gel offers such a strong hold is that it has a wax base, including lanolin. It hardens onto your hair within minutes after application (on damp hair). If you want a more tousled look, apply it to dry hair, and you can also use your hair dryer to create more volume.
It also works for men of different types of lengths. Again, if you want a product that provides a firm, all-day hold, this is a gel for you.
You’ll also like the Hair Hard Up Gel’s non-stick, non-greasy texture. Meanwhile, it has a clean scent that’s so light that others may not notice it, which isn’t necessarily a bad thing. It has some shine, but it’s not as glossy as other products that have a firm hold.
You shouldn’t experience any flakes with this gel, but it’s harder to wash out of your hair than many other styling products (which comes with having such a superior hold). Still, you only need to use a small amount of it to reap its benefits.
- Superior hold
- Nice shine that’s excessive
- Works on many hair types and styles
- Harder to wash out
This gel’s primary attribute – its hold – is excellent enough for it to merit inclusion on many “best-of” reviews. But you’ll also love its fragrance and subtle scent, as well as its versatility.
If you have long, thick hair – lucky bastard – then you know that getting a long-lasting hold is often challenging. Redken’s Stand Tough Extreme Hold Gel has a solution, however.
Just as you’d expect from a product with Extreme Hold in the name, Redken’s gel provides an extreme hold that, unless you get stuck in a wind tunnel, will last you all day. It’s also ideal for hairstyles that have a lot of texture and need a bit of height.
It also creates the sharp definition you need for many styles, so it’s not your kind of gel if you prefer something lightweight with a lower to medium hold.
Surprisingly, the Stand Tough Extreme Hold Gel gives you some wiggle room regarding restyling. Yes, it has almost a vice-like grip, but not so intense that you can’t give your luxurious locks a little touch-up as the day goes on. All you need to do is put a bit of water on your fingers and work it through your hair.
It also has a lighter shine, at least when compared to other gels that lean on the side of glossiness. You won’t get a dry, matte-like look with the Stand Tough Extreme Hold Gel but one that looks a bit more natural than “wet.”
You’ll notice a light, crisp scent when you apply this gel that’s more pleasing than overpowering. A little of it goes a long way, for sure, and it also washes out fairly easily. Even better, you won’t notice any tell-tale flakes in your hair after you’ve applied it.
- For men who want a gel with a firm hold
- Adds sharp definition to your hairstyle
- Works well on longer hairstyles
- May feel a little sticky
Redken’s Stand Tough gel is all about the hold, and that’s what many men prefer. But it doesn’t leave an overly-glossy finish, and it’s not difficult to wash it out of your hair between applications.
OK, so this hair gel isn’t targeting bodybuilders, although we’re sure they’re welcome to use it. But Jack Black’s hair gel is for men who want a clean, natural feel to their hair without needing a heavy dose of chemicals to do it. Or, a set of barbells.
Jack Black prides itself on the natural and organic ingredients it uses to make it’s many men’s grooming products. The company is a recent newcomer to the market but has ascended thanks to the high quality of everything it makes – including its Body Building Hair Gel.
The gel is made through Jack Black’s patented PureScience process that doesn’t include parabens, fragrances, or artificial coloring. All of its products are cruelty-free, and its gel is dermatologist-tested.
If you’re looking for a gel that has a lightweight, non-sticky feel without residue, then the Body Building Hair Gel is one that you should consider. It gives you the right amount of control – although its hold isn’t as firm as some hair gels – while leaving a light shine. You’ll also appreciate its fresh, clean scent.
Jack Black’s Body Building Hair Gel also comes in a convenient, travel-friendly size that fits nicely into your kit bag.
- Leaves a natural look and shine
- All-natural and organic ingredients
- Leaves no sticky residue
- Not for men who want a super firm hold
The Body Building Hair Gel represents yet another quality product in the Jack Black line. It’s lightweight and never heavy and helps you attain the look you want from your hair.
We’ve already reviewed American Crew’s Firm Hold Styling Gel for men, but its Spray Gel also deserves high praise. While it doesn’t have the kind of hold as the Styling Gel, it’s still strong enough to keep your hair in place during the day.
Meanwhile, it offers other benefits you won’t find in most gels, including that it comes with sunscreen that provides a barrier against the sun’s harmful UV rays. Moreover, it includes hair-friendly ingredients such as sage, ginseng, and Quillaja, which comes from the soapbark tree and is effective for treating itching and dandruff.
You can use the Spray Gel for Men on wet and dry hair. It provides a medium hold – it’s not as stiff as other styling sprays, such as hairspray – and it maintains your hair’s natural look without the shine. It’s also effective on all hair lengths and adds volume.
Another thing you’ll like about American Crew’s Spray Gel for Men is that it makes it easy to style and control your hair. Once your style is set, spray the gel evenly over your hair for a nice, long-lasting hold.
- Helps make styling easier
- Contains sunscreen
- Has a natural look and feel
- For some, the spray is harder to control
American Crew has another winner with its Spray Gel for Men. It provides a nice, even hold, and has additional benefits such as sun protection and adding volume to your hair.
Mitch stands for Paul Mitchell’s premium line of men’s styling products – not that the company’s regular list of products wasn’t strong enough. Paul Mitchell, after all, has a lofty reputation in the hair care field and it’s well-deserved.
The Mitch Steady Grip Hair Gel lives up to that reputation for a variety of reasons. It’s easy to use and provides a lasting hold, although not as firm of a hold as some other gels. Then again, not every man wants a stronger hold and many prefer that their hair have some “movement.”
It also has a nice shine although, like its hold, is a more medium strength than anything else. It will leave your hair with a nice finish, but one that’s not too shiny or oily-looking. And it has an alcohol-free formula that won’t dry out your hair or cause unwanted flakes.
Mitch Steady Grip Hair Gel comes in a compact tube that makes it easy to get the right amount of gel you need without having a lot go to waste.
- Well-respected brand name
- Medium, not-too-stiff hold
- Leaves hair with a natural look
- Some users prefer a longer-lasting hold
It’s no surprise that Paul Mitchell’s product line includes a quality hair gel. The Steady Grip Hair Gel leaves your hair feeling natural without being too stiff or too dry.
What’s The Right Way to Apply Hair Gel?
Among hair gel’s many advantages is that it’s easy to apply. It takes some finesse, sure, but it’s not the same as say, juggling knives (which is best left to the professionals). Here are some tips:
1. The amount
How much gel you use per application depends on your hair length and preferred hairstyle, for starters. As a general rule, a nickel to a quarter-sized amount is sufficient for shorter hair. You’ll need a slight bit more for longer hair.
Perhaps the most important thing to remember about this step is that you don’t want to use too much gel. You won’t like how your hair looks with too much gel in it – a bit too greasy, for starters – and you run the risk of clumps forming, which is never a good look. Also, applying too much gel can clog the pores of your scalp.
2. Prepare for application
Once you’ve squeezed out the right amount of gel in your hair, rub it between the palms of your hands until you’ve formed an even coating. This is an important step in preventing clumps of product from showing up in your hair.
3. Use it on clean hair
You’ll get better results if you apply your gel to freshly-washed hair. Make sure to use a quality shampoo. Any excess grease or dirt may make it more difficult to achieve your preferred style, and leave your hair feeling a little too crunchy.
4. Styling it
It’s your choice whether you work the hair gel into your preferred style by using your hands or a comb. Using your hands is particularly effective if you prefer a messier look, and if you have curly hair when you can use a scrunching motion.
While some hair professionals say it’s OK to comb the gel into to make sure you evenly distribute it, others say to brush and style your hair before putting in the gel. Some gels and even pomades are meant to be combed in the hair, but that’s not always the case.
Hair Gel vs. All The Rest
Finding a styling product that works for you is difficult only in that there are so many choices. From gels to waxes to pomades to hairspray, something is calling your name. Here’s a look at gel and some other hair products, including their characteristics and the purpose they serve.
Hair gel is no newcomer when it comes to styling products; in fact, its roots (no pun intended) extend back to the ancient Egyptians, and perhaps even beyond. They’ve come a long way over the past few thousand years and remain a popular choice among modern men.
While gels vary from brand to brand, most of them have a medium to high hold and a high shine. Gel keeps your hair in place and, in many cases, gives your hair a somewhat crunchy look that won’t have a lot of bounce. But again, the amount of shine and hold often varies from product to product.
If you have hair or a hairstyle that’s difficult to keep in place, gel is a product you should seriously consider purchasing. Most gels have a high alcohol content, which can dry out your hair if left in all day, and other may leave some flakes behind.
While gel is versatile enough for use on most hair lengths, short to long, it’s a particularly good option for men with thick hair. It’s also handy for achieving classic, old-school looks (think Elvis and John Travolta), but you can also use it for touch-ups to keep pesky stray hairs in place, especially for hairstyles in which the sides grow in different textures.
Gel vs. Pomade
Like gel, pomade provides a firm hold that’s stronger than many other styling products, and many of the best brands today are water-based to help create a lightweight, soft texture that’s easy to wash out.
Some pomades are oil-based, which offer a firmer hold than water-based products, as well as a higher shine. But, as you might expect, oil-based pomades are harder to wash out and not as easy to restyle during the day.
Pomades are helpful for attaining a variety of popular styles, including the pompadour, quiff, and slicked-back. However, some pomades have more of a matte finish, which tend to work better for hairstyles worn in professional settings. Either way, pomades come with a variety of holds.
Gel vs. Wax
Most waxes are thicker than gel and offer a medium to strong hold, but they’re smooth and add volume and texture to hair. Waxes tend to be oil-based, which makes them harder to wash out, although there are plenty of water-based waxes available.
One of wax’s attributes is that it absorbs excess grease that’s common in men with naturally oily hair. But that also means that it can dry out more quickly than, say, pomade. You’ll find waxes in both shine and matte finishes.
Gel vs. Paste
Most pastes provide a medium hold and shine and have a thicker consistency than most styling products. Pastes add volume and texture to your hair, especially if you apply it when your hair is damp and before you dry it.
Among paste’s many attributes are that it’s versatile and effective for styling most hair lengths and types and that it’s excellent for messy styles that look as if you’ve just rolled out of bed but still maintain a great, natural style.
Paste is typically water-based and easy to wash out of hair, as well as easy to restyle when your favorite look gets out of place. Another thing to like about paste is that you can use it on your beard.
Gel vs. Cream
Cream differs from gel and pomade in that it provides a low hold without as much stiffness or greasiness. Hair cream has a medium shine that many say is more natural compared to other styling products.
A cream is a good option for men with thinning or fine hair who don’t like to use pomade or wax. It’s lightweight, so it can feel like you’re not wearing any product at all. Creams also range in texture somewhere between lightweight lotions and those that have a wax-like consistency.
Gel vs. Other Products
We’ve only touched on a few of the many hair styling products available to men. Just know that there are many others: mousse, clay, sea salt spray, mud/putty, hairspray, and more.
Gel, as we’ve already discussed, provides a firmer hold than many products and also tends to have a higher shine but, again, that may vary from product to product. In any case, it’s in your best interest to do all the research you can before choosing a product that’s right for you.
Why Did We Choose This Products?
Since we never pick names out of a hat to choose the products for our reviews, a more specific approach is required. There are a plethora of hair gels to choose from, so narrowing it down to get our top 9 required answering a few questions:
- Does it do what it says it does?
- Does it have a lot of positive reviews, both from users and peers?
- Does it fit into a variety of budgets?
- Will it keep your favorite hairstyle in place?
We also looked for gels that fit a variety of hair lengths and textures and examined important considerations such as their hold and shine. We think it’s a well-rounded list that’s helpful to any man.
As always, we welcome your comments and suggestions. Do you have a favorite hair gel? If so, why do you like it? Have you tried any of the gels on our list? We’d love to hear from you.