Aging is often a pain in the ass. Many of us exercise, eat healthy foods and even practice techniques that help ease stress.
But no matter what we do, signs of aging still appear – like gray hair – that symbolize the relentless march of time. Still, we fight back by doing things such as coloring our hair, which is the subject of this post.
We want to give you a fighting chance by examining the best hair dye for men – including Just For Men’s AutoStop Men’s Comb-In Hair Color Covering up those gray roots is no simple task, but we’re here to help with buying and application tips, as well as the things that make for a good hair dye and color.
Let’s begin with some hair dye buying tips.
Table of Contents
Balding Beards is reader-supported. When you buy through external links, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more.
|Just for Men Autostop Men’s Comb-In Hair Color||Check on Amazon →|
|Clairol Natural Instincts Semi-Permanent Hair Color Kit||Check on Amazon →|
|Just for Men Touch of Gray Comb-In Men’s Hair Color||Check on Amazon →|
|Just for Men Control GX Grey Reducing Shampoo||Check on Amazon →|
|Bigen EZ Color Hair Color for Men – Jet Black||Check on Amazon →|
|Pure & Natural Henna Powder for Hair Dye||Check on Amazon →|
|Goldwell for Men Reshade Grey Blending Power Shot (Cool Ash Light Brown)||Check on Amazon →|
|Manly Guy Black Hair Beard & Mustache Color||Check on Amazon →|
Before you buy: 9 Things to consider when purchasing a hair dye for men
It always helps to be a wise shopper before purchasing any product and buying hair dye is no exception. Here are a few tips that will help you make a smart decision when shopping for hair dye.
1. Know your shade
Your first step in purchasing hair dye is identifying your natural hair color. Why? Because doing so sets the foundation for choosing your desired (dye) shade. When in doubt, ask your barber or stylist – who can help identify your hair’s tones.
2. What’s your goal?
It’s important to have a good idea of what you want to accomplish with hair dyeing. If you’re looking to make a dramatic change, then hair experts suggest sticking with colors that are no more than two shades lighter or darker. If you’re going for a lighter shade, you may need a permanent hair color. Or, if you’re looking to cover a few greys, then you probably don’t need a permanent dye.
Just a note on covering grey hair: look for a product that specifically says something like “good for grey hair.” Grey hair isn’t always easy to cover but some hair dye brands are designed specifically for that purpose.
3. Permanent, temporary, semi-permanent, etc.
There are four categories of hair dye: temporary, semi-permanent, demi-permanent, and permanent. Temporary dye, as its name suggests, washes out after a couple of shampoos, while semi-permanent dye washes out after several (even as many as 12) shampoos. Demi-permanent dye takes many more shampoos (up to 30 in some cases), while permanent dyes change the natural pigment of hair and last until the hair grows out when you cut it. Many permanent dyes contain ammonia.
4. What’s the formula?
The best hair dyes won’t damage your hair or irritate your skin when used as directed. If you have sensitive skin, you may want to purchase an ammonia-free dye for less irritation. Demi-permanent dyes don’t include ammonia. The fact is, any product with a lower amount of chemicals is safer in the long run. Chemical products may strip the hair of essential oils and nutrients or, in extreme cases, stunt hair growth.
5. Ignore the model
Just like you can’t judge a book by its cover, you shouldn’t judge a hair dye by the model on the box. The color of his hair isn’t necessarily a replica of the dye’s true color. The good news, however, is that most dyes come with a color chart on the side of the box that matches the color you want to achieve. You should also keep in mind that some hair dyes are darker at the beginning but fade a bit after you’ve shampooed your hair a couple of times.
6. Be wary of PPD
Many people are allergic to a chemical called para-phenylenediamine (PPD) found in some hair color products. Symptoms may include scalp irritation, itching, flaking, and blisters, and if they last for several days, you should see a doctor. There are PPD-free hair dyes and colors available; if PPD is a concern, be sure to check the label.
7. Can’t stand the smell?
Many permanent hair dyes have a strong odor – primarily because of the ammonia – but there are ammonia-free semi-permanent dyes if you have a sensitive nose.
8. The color
Of course, you have to consider each dye’s color – after all, that’s the part visible to you and everyone else. Hair dye comes in a wide variety of colors – although men’s hair dyes tend to have fewer shades than women’s hair dye – and, again, the one you choose depends on your hair-coloring goals. Here are a few things to think about when choosing men’s hair dye colors:
- Choose a color that adds a subtle change to your hair. A color that makes it overly-obvious that you’ve dyed your hair is often a source of embarrassment for men, so stick to colors close to your natural color (not more than one or two shades lighter or darker).
- The best hair dyes don’t look flat or “brassy.”
- If you’re seeking a warmer tone, the dye’s label should say something like “golden” or “warm.” For cooler tones, “ash” is a good indicator.
Applying hair dye is often a messy job and something of a challenge, which we’ll delve into a bit later. Many brands come with tools such as gloves, applicator nozzles, and easy-to-handle highlighting wands. It always helps to check out user reviews to see how easy a dye is to apply and whether it’s drippy or messy.
Next, let’s take a look at our men’s hair dye reviews.
The 7 best hair dyes for men 2020
Any list of best hair dye reviews wouldn’t be complete without a Just For Men product. Just For Men is, after all, always in the conversation when discussing the best hair color brand for men, and they have a plethora of products from which to choose. They have great beard dye as well.
The AutoStop Men’s Comb-In Hair Color is a signature product of the JFM franchise and is easy to use. It also prevents dye job screw-ups because it can’t get too dark – hence, the “AutoStop” mention in its name.
In short, this dye is a foolproof way for men to hide grey hair and for getting a natural result that doesn’t scream, “Look! I just dyed my hair!” You’ll get the right amount of color every time without looking like you dunked your head in the dye.
Indeed, the AutoStop Men’s Comb-In Hair Color has many attributes:
- It comes pre-mixed, which means that you don’t have to mess around with the dye and the developer to get your desired color before you apply it.
- It doesn’t contain ammonia or peroxide, and gently changes your hair color.
- The AutoStop function shuts off the target color after 10 minutes so it can’t get too dark. Instead, the color blends easily into the rest of your hair to create a more natural look.
- It doesn’t leave your hair feeling stiff but instead makes it soft and manageable.
- The Just For Men AutoStop line comes in a variety of natural-looking shades so you won’t have any problem finding one that best fits your natural hair color.
- The AutoStop color should last you about two months although it may last a shorter time if your hair grows back quickly.
- While AutoStop For Men is designed for use in your hair, you can also apply it to your beard.
- Easy to use
- Keeps users from over-coloring their hair
- Contains no ammonia or peroxide
- The color doesn’t last as long as some reviewers would like
Just For Men is a major player in the men’s hair dye market, and it didn’t rise to the top by creating shoddy products. The AutoStop Men’s Comb-In Color makes it easy to dye your hair and to achieve a natural, not overdone, look.
Clairol’s Natural Instincts hair dye for men is another product that doesn’t use ammonia, which can be harsh on hair, and it includes a variety of antioxidants and other natural ingredients that are gentle on your nice-looking locks.
It also comes in a variety of shades that provide plenty of coloring options for men and women.
For men, Natural Instincts provides an excellent solution for strategically covering up those grey hairs to give you a more youthful look. You’ll make your hair’s natural shade stand out without looking like you’ve created a new you that isn’t, well, “you.”
Let’s begin with the ingredients. Clairol Natural Instincts includes hair-friendly ingredients such as aloe, protein, and vitamin E. They help to make a gentler dye that’s not too harsh or one that may potentially damage hair; instead, they help condition and protect hair while it’s changing the color.
The Hair Color Kit For Men is – and it’s in the title – semi-permanent (or demi-permanent) in that it will last quite a long time before you need to re-color your hair. How long? Well, you should get one to three months out of a single coloring. And, as mentioned, you won’t drastically change your hair color (but you’ll get rid of the grey) as long as you choose the right shade.
The kit comes with a developer and applying it shouldn’t take more than 10 minutes. Moreover, Clairol is known for its true-to-life coloring and ranks among the best hair color for men. It’s certainly among the best men’s grey hair treatment, as well, and – according to some reviewers – among the best hair dye for men with short hair.
- Proven brand name
- Creates a natural look
- Some say it leaves hair feeling a little coarse
Clairol’s Natural Instincts hair color kit helps you get rid of pesky grey hairs without looking like you spray-painted on a new color. It’s also ammonia-free and contains natural ingredients that help nourish the hair.
Back to the good folks at Just For Men, who can also lay claim to the best dye hair for men with grey (or “gray”, whichever you prefer) hair with its Touch of Gray Comb-In hair color.
Not that this dye gets rid of all of your grey hair, mind you. But it takes away enough to leave you with a salt and pepper look that many men (and women) prefer over a complete grey “takeover,” if you will.
Besides, removing all of your grey hair once you’ve reached a certain age may not look as well as you’d think. It can create an unnatural look that everyone notices for all the wrong reasons. But why not rock the George Clooney touch-of-grey look with a hair dye that provides just enough grey hair coverage?
We think it’s a worth a try.
The Touch of Gray Comb-In hair color falls under the “temporary” dye category because it lasts for only as long as it takes for your grey hair to grow back. It’s easy to apply and shouldn’t take much more than five minutes to do so, and comes with an easy comb-in applicator.
Just For Men’s Touch of Gray comes pre-mixed so there’s no mess or messing around with developer to get the color that’s most natural for you. Just For Men advises that you should try the lightest color first if you have trouble choosing between two shades. It’s always easier to go darker if needed.
JFM also makes a mustache dye that’s just as easy to apply and helps you look like the sophisticated, gracefully-aging gent that you are. Oh, and if you’re looking for a men’s hair color shampoo, check out the
- Leaves just the right amount of grey for a distinguished look
- Easy to apply
- No mix and no mess
- It may be a bit darker than you’d think, so choose your shade accordingly
Just For Men’s Touch of Gray takes the edge off or your grey hair without making it look too obvious. You’ll look younger, but not ridiculously so, and it comes from a company that knows a thing or two about men’s hair coloring.
There’s nothing subtle about Bigen’s EZ Color Hair Color. It’s bold and, if you’re hoping to cover those grey hairs without leaving a trace, it’s a product you definitely should consider.
It’s also for you if you’re looking for hair color or dye that’s easy to apply and doesn’t leave a mess. It’s a cream that you comb into your hair and requires no mixing. Even better, you can use it on your beard, mustache, and eyebrows.
But back to the color, the Jet Black version, that is. It’s very vivid and – yes – bold, and will help you attain a more youthful, fresh appearance. It’s also among the best hair dye for black men, if not the best.
We also like that the Bigen EZ Color Hair Color contains no ammonia and is hydrogen peroxide-free. It won’t leave stains on your skin because there’s no excess dripping as with other hair dyes and colors. The only time stains may occur is if you have dry, flaky skin.
EZ Color also provides some conditioning because its list of ingredients includes aloe extract, while olive oil helps to leave hair healthy-looking with a natural finish.
Another thing to note is that EZ Color is a permanent hair color that lasts longer than non-permanent brands.
EZ Color’s instructions say to leave the color cream in your hair for 10 minutes after before shampooing and rinsing hair. You can leave it in your hair longer to create a darker shade, although you should never leave it in for more than 30 minutes.
- Easy to use
- Contains no ammonia
- Bold, vivid color
- May cause light itching
EZ Color will get rid of grey hair quickly, which is the solution that most users of hair dye and color seek. It’s easy to apply, leaves no mess, and works well on your beard and mustache, too.
Illinois-based The Henna Guys is a company that takes natural and organic seriously. It sources quality ingredients from ethical producers around the world and uses them in all of its products, which includes hair care and skincare.
The Henna Guys’ Pure & Natural Henna Powder For Hair Dye follows the company model for 100% natural ingredients and is arguably the best natural hair dye for men. And, just as you’d expect, it’s made from henna, a plant with a long history for providing color to the hair and skin.
But henna also has hair health benefits, including that it stimulates hair growth and strengthens the scalp. That makes it ideal for men with thinning hair who want more volume and thickness, but it also works for men with any hair type. Another benefit of henna is that it helps to condition hair.
The biggest difference between henna hair dyes and many other types, however, is that henna doesn’t contain harmful stuff like parabens, PPD, or allergenic preservatives. Meanwhile, henna dye fades naturally and without leaving obvious demarcation lines.
Henna, as mentioned, is a plant whose uses date back thousands of years. It grows in dry, hot climates and its leaves are dried and ground into a fine powder and made into a paste which is used to dye hair, skin, and fingernails.
While henna’s natural color is reddish brown, companies like The Henna Guys make dyes in many different shades, with each one made from pure henna and plant ingredients.
As you’d expect, The Henna Guys’ Pure & Natural Henna Powder contains no chemicals or other harmful additives. Instead, it’s 100% natural, raw, vegan, and pesticide-free. And they have 13 different shades from which to choose.
- Excellent natural hair dye
- Contains no chemicals or other harmful ingredients
- Strengthens and conditions the hair and scalp
- May cause dry scalp in some users
Henna is a good option if you’re looking for a hair dye that’s completely natural. It’s not only natural, but it also works and you’ll like how your hair looks after you’ve applied it.
One of the best things about Goldwell’s Grey Blending Power Shot is that it provides the convenient use of foam in a product that promises to get rid of too-noticeable grey hairs. There’s no overly-messy application process and it takes only about five minutes to cover your hair.
And it works.
The Goldwell For Men ReShade helps men to get a more youthful, energetic look without appearing contrived. It looks natural, which should always be a goal in coloring your hair, and not something that all but screams “fake.” It also leaves a masculine tone that won’t fade over time, and you won’t notice any reddish or warm tones after you’ve shampooed your hair.
Even better, it doesn’t include ammonia and is easier on the hair than a lot of dyes and other hair color products. Many men are allergic to products that contain ammonia.
If you’re having a hard time determining your natural hair color, Goldwell recommends choosing a lighter shade. If that’s too light, then you should apply a darker shade immediately. Again, the application process is quick and not nearly as messy as with hair dyes.
- Easy application process
- Provides natural, grey blending
- Doesn’t last as long as more permanent dyes and colors
Goldwell for Men ReShade represents an innovative, easy way to get rid of grey hairs without being too obvious about it. The coloring looks natural, not artificial, and has a nice masculine look.
Another henna hair color kit worth serious consideration is Manly Guy’s Black Hair Beard & Mustache Color. Made from pure henna – with all-natural herbs – Manly Guy’s coloring doesn’t contain any harmful junk such as PPD’s and peroxide, and it’s hypoallergenic.
But does it work?
That’s the million-dollar question with any product, and regarding Manly Guy’s Black Hair Beard & Mustache Color the answer is a solid “yes.” Many reviewers say it works as well, if not better, than traditional hair color kits that include chemicals, and covers up those greys that make you look a bit older than your years.
Meanwhile, it’s other big advantage – that it’s chemical-free – makes it worth your investment, as well. You don’t have to worry about the itching, burning, rash, or other irritating reactions, that you do with many non-natural dyes and colors. It’s also vitamin-enriched and vegan and helps make your thicker and more healthy overall.
Manly Guy’s coloring works on all hair and skin types, and on all types of treated hair – from color-treated to permed, to straightened – to any hair that’s chemically-colored. It also offers a variety of other colors, including strawberry blonde, dark brown, copper, dark red, and more.
Another plus is that the coloring is easy to use. You only need to add water, mix it into a paste, and then apply. Each kit comes with everything you need to color your hair multiple times: gloves, hair cap, and instructions.
Some say that Manly Guy’s product leaves your hair with a green tint immediately after application, but that the shade fades away after the coloring sets in your hair completely.
- Contains no harmful chemicals
- Vitamin-enriched and vegan
- Doesn’t irritate the skin or scalp
- The total application process is slower than with some dyes and colors
Manly Guy’s Beard & Mustache and Color helps you to get the hair color you desire without irritating your skin and scalp. Packed with natural ingredients, it even helps your hair to be thicker and healthier.
Applying your men’s hair dye
Once you’ve purchased your hair dye it’s time for the true test, i.e., applying it to your hair. While dyeing your hair isn’t as easy as, say, applying a pomade, it’s shouldn’t be intimidating, either. All you need is some time, patience, courage, and the commitment to following the directions that come with each dye. Here are some common steps to follow:
1. Block off some time
The process of correctly applying hair will take some time. The last thing you want to do is to rush through the steps and end up with a coloring that’s cringe-worthy.
2. Have the right tools
Don’t get started until you have everything you need to do the job right. And that includes:
- A coloring brush, if one doesn’t come with the product.
- Latex gloves, because you don’t want to get dye all over your hands – or any part of your body, for that matter.
- A trash bag or another kind of plastic covering that protects your sink and surrounding area from dripping dye, which can cause stains easily.
- A color developer kit, which comes with most hair dyes.
3. Strip down
No, there’s no need to get naked (but feel free if you so desire), but take off your shirt, pants and other clothing that may get ruined by the dye. At the least, wear an old T-shirt that you can toss in the trash when the job’s finished.
4. Guard your hairline
Many hair professionals advise that you put Vaseline or another kind of lotion on the outer edge of your hairline to prevent dye from bleeding down onto your forehead.
5. Mix the dye
This step is where following directions becomes crucial. Each product comes with a list of instructions for mixing the dye color and developer to create the final composition that ends up in your hair. As a general rule, if you want a deeper color, you should increase the ratio of hair color to developer. But be careful that you don’t overdo it and end up with a dye that’s more than two shades darker than your normal hair color.
6. Brush on the dye
Once you’ve developed your desired color, use a brush to apply the dye to the targeted areas of your hair. Keep an eye on the temples and sides of your head while leaving some natural color visible to help make the overall job look more realistic. Note: some people apply the color to a comb with a tint brush and then delicately comb the targeted areas for subtle coverage.
7. Let it sit
Let the dye sit in your hair for the suggested time frame for each product. In most cases, it’s only five to 15 minutes. You can reduce the amount of time the dye sits in your hair to get a more natural look.
8. Rinse it
Rinse your hair out in the sink – the wider the sink, the better – or shower after you’ve left the dye in your hair for the required amount of time.
And now you’re ready to face the world!
Hair dye vs. hair color – What’s the difference?
People often confuse hair dye with hair color – and vice versa – and with good reason. Hair dye is a relatively newer term and natural dyes were used to color clothes. But synthetic dyes began to replace natural ones, in part because they last longer, and soon became popular for coloring human hair.
Confusion still reigns, however, because many companies that manufacture dye refer to their products as hair “color.” No one is quite sure why, or perhaps because dye suggests a harsher product, but many hair color products are actually hair dyes.
Forgive us if you’re still scratching your head about this subject. There really is a scientific difference between hair dye and hair color and it comes down to this: hair dye goes inside strands of hair to provide color while hair color stays on the surface (like paint stays on the surface of a wall). That said, hair color fades faster than hair dye.
Hair dye, generally speaking, consists of strong chemical mixtures that help make it more permanent than hair color. Hair color doesn’t reach the roots of the hair but acts as a coating on the surface of the hair. Regular re-application of hair color is a must for maintaining a well-groomed look, but not as important with more permanent hair dye.
In either case, however, any new growing hair will consist of its natural color whether you use dye or color.
Our method for choosing these products
There aren’t a lot of hair dyes and color for men when compared to other hair products, and especially when compared to hair color for women. Certain brands dominate the playing field, so to speak, with Just For Men leading the way.
Fewer choices don’t make it easier to choose products for our review because it leaves less room for comparison. But those that made our list satisfied our expectations for effectiveness while earning high marks from users and other reviewers. Ease of application is another consideration, as is each product’s list of ingredients. We always like grooming products that have natural ingredients and are less harsh on the hair, skin, or beard.
In any case, we think you’ll find our list helpful.
Do you use hair dye? Have you tried any on our list? If so, how did they work? We always welcome your comments and suggestions and would love to hear from you!
YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE:
Get more content like this and enter the monthly giveaway for the new Spectral.BRD beard-stimulating serum by DS Laboratories!
Thank you for subscribing.
Something went wrong.